10 Best Spiced Rum Brands January 2015

Are you a huge fan of spiced rum? Rum lovers from around the world will enjoy exploring this list and choosing a top spiced rum label of their own. We all have unique tastes and preferences, but it's safe to say that every type of spiced rum listed here offers delicious flavor and quality. Each of these top-shelf bottles has been picked based on a strict set of qualifying statistics. Whether you need spiced rum for a wedding celebration or simply want to add a new bottle to your collection, you can't go wrong with one of these great brands. The companies below have been reviewed based on a wide range of qualitative and quantitative statistics. In some cases, variable listing fees effect position on this list; however only highly-regarded firms are accepted through our review analysis. Learn more about our ranking process here.

 Top Spiced Rum Label Logo: Captain Morgan Black Spiced

#1 of 10 Leading Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum combines thick, dark blackstrap Caribbean rum with a variation of the Captains' well-known signature spice blend. It is an excellent choice for bold, flavorful tropical drinks and sweet dessert drinks. Many rum aficionados will likely also enjoy its distinctive charms neat or on the rocks. Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum is darker, richer, sweeter and more intensely flavorful than regular Captain Morgan. This makes it somewhat less versatile than the standard spirit, but also arguably more memorable. Notably spice notes include cassia bark and clove.

 Leading Spiced Rum Label Logo: Siesta Key Spiced Rum

#2 of 10 Top Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Siesta Key Spiced Rum is a spicy, sweet liquor like no other. This award-winning artisan rum is infused with real spices and honey for rich flavor. It is "possibly the tastiest rum in the world", according to Miami New Times. It's no surprise because Siesta Key Spiced Rum is made in small batches in the U.S. without the use of artificial flavors or sweeteners. It is a true standout among the competition and worthy of The Caribbean Rum Beer Festival's Top Ranking in 2013.

 Leading Spiced Rum Label Logo: Shellback Spiced Rum

#3 of 10 Top Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Shellback Spiced Rum is a beverage from the West Indies. It has been in development since 1893. There are neutral tones as well as heavier notes that give the rum its spicy flavor. The rum is one that has passed through pot stills. There are floral notes when you open the bottle as well as an undertone of vanilla that blends well with the flowers. This rum is one that although spicy has a smooth start and finish.

 Top Spiced Rum Label Logo: Sailor Jerry

#4 of 10 Best Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Sailor Jerry spiced rum is named for famed golden age tattoo artist Norman "Sailor Jerry" Collins. A pioneer in the world of tattoo art, he combined traditional American techniques with an Asian approach he picked up while traveling to the Far East on a steamer vessel. While any tangible connection between Collins and the rum that bears his nickname is questionable at best, it is still a very enjoyable spirit. At 92 proof it is quite strong, too. It boasts crowd-pleasing flavors of vanilla, caramel and sweet black cherry and features a rich golden-brown color. Thanks to its intense, bold and straightforward flavor profile, it holds up well in icy, fruity summer-time drinks.

 Best Spiced Rum Label Logo: Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum

#5 of 10 Leading Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum is an intense, full-bodied spirit. This 92 proof rum is delicious served on the rocks with a mixer such as cola or ginger ale. Due to its bold taste, it also holds up well when mixed with fruit juices, flavored syrups and other ingredients typically used in colorful tropical drinks. Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum is produced in the U.S. Virgin Islands on the island of St. Croix. It is distilled five times for smoothness and features a pleasing assortment of added spices, including clove, cinnamon and vanilla.

 Top Spiced Rum Label Logo: The Kraken Black Spiced Rum

#6 of 10 Top Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - The Kraken Black Spiced Rum is one that has strong notes. It is a heavy drink that comes in a dark bottle. The rum has a tar color after being aged for several years. This drink is produced in Indiana. Most of the color is from caramel being added, but there is some of the oak barrel aging mixed in for the dark tones. The rum has a minty smell as well as a peppermint taste with a hint of pepper.

 Top Spiced Rum Label Logo: Margaritaville Premium Jamaican Spiced Rum

#7 of 10 Leading Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Margaritaville Premium Jamaican Spiced Rum has a lower proof than other rums. This is a drink that is a play on the popular Jimmy Buffet song of the same name. There are aromas of buttercream and coconut cake. These notes give the rum its sweet taste. There is a delicate spice instead of something overpowering that takes away from the enjoyment of the beverage. It has an alcohol content of 35% by volume. Depths of pistachio and cherry flavors linger.

 Best Spiced Rum Label Logo: Brinley Gold Shipwreck Spiced Rum

#8 of 10 Best Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - Brinely Gold Shipwreck Spiced Rum is a flavorful, hand-crafted rum from the island of St. Kitts. The rum is dedicated to an actual British ship that sank off the coast of St. Kitts in 1782. Crafted from the sugar cane of the exotic island, this beautiful, amber-colored rum is molasses based and is infused with the natural flavors of nutmeg, orange, vanilla, clove, and a unique blend of island spices. This award-winning rum received a rating of "Exceptional" from the Beverage Tasting Institute and a rating of "Very Good" from Wine Enthusiast. Brinley Gold Shipwreck Spiced Rum is an excellent rum that is delicious served neat, on the rocks, or in any rum-based cocktail.

 Best Spiced Rum Label Logo: Cruzan No. 9 Spiced Rum

#9 of 10 Best Spiced Rum Labels of 2015 - This award-winning spiced rum is wood-aged and flavored with nine spices that create a delectable flavor and exude a warm aroma. The senses are engaged with the familiar yet bold taste of vanilla, spices and caramel that are distinctive to spiced rum. Cinnamon, nutmeg, and other spices are complimented with an undertone of toasted wood to ensure a unique flavor. Cruzan No. 9 Spiced Rum can easily be recognized by its exotic flavor, natural spices, and vivacious amber color.

Previous 10 Top Spiced Rum Brands

Alcohol Aficionado is a new type of awards organization for the spirits industry. Our web-based model allows for greater distribution of our publication and a wider acceptance of registrants on a rolling-basis.

Site badge for all Best Rum Brand award winners